At Yotpo, we’ve long championed transparency and authenticity in the way brands engage with their customers – especially when it comes to reviews and endorsements. Recent enforcement actions by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) against NextMed and Rytr have reinforced just how critical this commitment is.
Key Takeaways
- The FTC is cracking down on deceptive marketing, making review transparency crucial for brands.
- Fake reviews and suppressed negative feedback are unlawful and a growing enforcement priority.
- Brands must be diligent in how they collect and moderate customer content to prove authenticity.
- Incentivized reviews are permissible if disclosed and not conditioned on positive sentiment.
- Using clear features like “verified buyer” badges and transparent incentive tags is essential for proving authenticity to skeptical consumers.
FTC Fake Reviews Crackdown: A Warning for Brands
In recent months, the FTC took action against telehealth provider NextMed, alleging it misled consumers with deceptive pricing claims and used fake reviews to market weight loss medications. According to the FTC’s complaint, NextMed suppressed negative reviews on Trustpilot by selectively challenging critical reviews, offering Amazon gift cards to consumers to remove or change negative reviews, and by conditioning refunds on consumers’ agreement to remove negative reviews. In addition, the complaint alleges that the company generated fake positive reviews that were posted on Trustpilot and used testimonials and before-and-after photos from people who were not NextMed clients and had not used their products.
Similarly, the FTC finalized an order against Rytr, a seller of AI testimonial tools, for providing fake review services to subscribers. The platform enabled sellers to publish fictitious positive reviews across major eCommerce marketplaces and business platforms, violating FTC rules and misleading consumers.
Together, these cases send a clear signal: fake reviews and manipulative marketing tactics are not a gray area – they are unlawful and clearly becoming enforcement priorities.
Why This Matters to your Brand
The rise of AI-generated content and increased competition over search, social & marketplace placements, are creating real risk for brands and consumers alike. The tighter enforcement, a trend we expect will only grow, is welcome intervention designed to ensure that consumers can continue to trust UGC, and it’s impact on trust and conversions will continue to grow. As the regulatory landscape tightens, it’s not enough to generate customer content. Brands should be stricter on how they collect and moderate content, and take actions to prove it’s real & trustworthy.
That’s why Yotpo is built to promote trust at every step. We offer strict verified buyer and incentive badges in reviews, moderation tools to catch suspicious content while also leveraging AI to make strict moderation seamless and accessible to brands of all sizes, and clear compliance workflows to ensure you stay aligned with FTC guidelines. To learn more about how Yotpo is working to promote an authentic review experience visit our previous publications.
Compliance Isn’t Just About Risk – It’s About Building Loyalty
Consumers are increasingly skeptical. They want to know that the reviews they’re reading are from real people, with real experiences. Brands that embrace this shift – that double down on authenticity, accountability, and transparency – will win long-term trust.
As these recent cases prove, shortcuts might offer short-term gain, but they carry long-term risk. At Yotpo, we’re helping brands build communities that are not just compliant, but credible, lasting, and trusted.
–
The FTC’s Fake Review Crackdown: Your FAQs Answered
As regulations tighten, many brands are asking what these changes mean in practice. Here are four important clarifications:
1. Are incentivized reviews illegal?
No, incentivized reviews are allowed if they meet FTC guidelines. Incentives must be clearly disclosed, and they cannot be conditional on a positive sentiment.
- Yotpo makes compliance easy by automatically tagging reviews as “incentivized” when a discount, loyalty points, or samples are offered.
- Yotpo’s official product sampling and seeding partners are all guided & certified to clearly mark reviews they send to Yotpo as such.
- Other affiliated and incentivized reviews, not directly through Yotpo or one of it’s official partners, such as employees, influencers and affiliates or friends and family reviews / incentives must be marked as such by store owners. Marking these reviews is quick and simple in the Yotpo moderation tool.
- This disclosure appears directly in the main product page reviews widget, ensuring transparency for shoppers.
- Importantly, reviewers must remain free to share their honest opinions – positive or negative.
2. Do we need to publish every review onsite?
Brands can moderate reviews, but suppression is unlawful without a legitimate reason. According to the FTC reviews can only be rejected if they contain offensive content, false claims, spam, private information, or are proven fake. Yotpo provides tools & safeguards to ensure that compliant review moderation is simple and effective.
- Auto-publishing: Brands can choose to automatically publish all reviews or apply a star-rating or AI sentiment filter. Reviews below the threshold must still be addressed.
- A list of profanity and stop words for auto publish, can be easily managed by brands, to which we recommend that brands add competitor & employee names, and other keywords that may give cause to reject a review in their specific category or store context so these reviews are manually evaluated.
- Built-in compliance: To avoid manipulation, Yotpo automatically publishes reviews not acted upon within 14 days. Every review that was manually rejected must include a valid reason for future reference / records.
- Yotpo integrates with the top CRM and service platforms to make sure moderation of reviews can be done in the tools and by the teams that are in charge of customer interactions. Yotpo also offers simple escalation & tagging capabilities.
- If you would like to outsource the moderation of reviews to an experienced and trusted team of moderators, Yotpo also offers optional moderation services for a fee.
These different layers of safeguards and features ensure authenticity and protect brands from regulatory risk while keeping review management effective and accessible to tens of thousands of brands.
3. Should brands be proactively checking if reviews were written by reviewers using AI?
The use of AI tools (such as chatgpt, perplexity & others), to write reviews by reviewers is not illegal by itself, so long as they do not contain false claims and are clearly badged in case of any type of affiliation or incentive. This is particularly true for reviews that were written by bonafide purchasers of the same product, which Yotpo’s technology automatically validates and marks as ‘verified buyer’ reviews, on any of our collection methods. Yotpo is designed to maximize the volume and coverage of these verified buyer reviews, and by design only verified buyer reviews are syndicated to Yotpo’s consumer facing partners, including social, search and retail channels.
4. Are Yotpo’s Smart Prompts (AI-generated prompts to recommend topics for more impactful review collection) and similar AI capabilities a compliance issue?
No. Smart Prompts simply guide real customers to leave richer, more helpful feedback. As long as the person writing the review is:
- A genuine purchaser or user of the product,
- Independent from the brand, and
- Transparent about any incentives received,
Smart Prompts remain fully compliant. They do not generate reviews, they only help real people express their experiences more effectively, and ensure reviews include answers to the topics other shoppers are most interested in learning about to make smarter, more accurate purchase decisions, helping them and brands reduce returns and increase overall purchase fit and CLTV.
Disclaimer
This information is not legal advice. While we do our best to provide useful information as a starting point, Yotpo advises all merchants to obtain professional legal advice to ensure compliance with all applicable laws.
Join a free demo, personalized to fit your needs